My grandfather came from southern Lebanon. When I read about an Israeli drone strike in Qabrikha, I think about the people who will use that road the next morning. I also think about a family in northern Israel trying to judge whether it is safe to raise children near the border. Each family has a reasonable expectation: someone with the authority to keep them safe should be able to explain what is happening a few miles from home.
On November 4, an Israeli drone struck two people riding a motorcycle in Qabrikha, killing one and wounding the other. According to security sources cited by TheStateOfIsrael.com, the riders had approached Israeli troops and posed an immediate threat. At the time of the report, authorities were still examining who the riders were and whether they had been armed. No affiliation with Hezbollah had been confirmed.
I support Israeli soldiers taking action to protect themselves when they face an immediate threat. A soldier can recognize danger before knowing the name or affiliation of the person approaching. The question afterward is what the troops observed that made this particular approach dangerous. The security sources gave their assessment. The investigation can help establish the facts behind it.
That distinction matters to both sides. If the riders are eventually identified as Hezbollah members, that would answer an important question about who they were. We would still want to understand what happened on the road. If investigators find no evidence of an affiliation, that finding alone would tell us little about what the soldiers saw at the time. One person died in this strike. Another was wounded. The findings deserve the same public attention as the initial report, whatever they turn out to be.
Three days earlier, the IDF had issued a separate statement about operations around Al-Khiam. It said its 769th Brigade had found weapons in a civilian home, including rockets and rifles, and had dismantled a storage site for explosive drones. Those findings were reported by the Israeli military in a different location. They give us no basis for identifying either rider in Qabrikha. They do, however, bring into focus a problem the Lebanese government has every reason to address on its own terms.
Consider what a weapons cache in a residential area means for the people who live nearby. A family can have no part in putting those weapons there and still face the consequences if the site comes under attack. Across the border, an Israeli family has no way to know whether a rocket in storage will stay there. Both have a stake in the Lebanese army being able to locate the weapons, remove them, and prevent anyone from putting them back. Beirut should want that authority for the sake of its own citizens. A government cannot give a village meaningful protection if an armed organization can decide, independently, what military risks that village will bear.
There is already a framework for what that authority should look like. In 2006, UN Security Council Resolution 1701 called for Israeli forces to withdraw south of the Blue Line and for the area between that line and the Litani River to be free of armed personnel and weapons other than those belonging to the Lebanese government or UNIFIL. Read together, those provisions speak to the two families I have in mind. One wants Lebanese sovereignty to mean something on the road outside its home. The other wants assurance that an armed group cannot use that road to prepare an attack.
In my view, Israel has a direct interest in a Lebanese army capable of exercising that authority. The more reliably Beirut can act on a report of an unauthorized weapons site and show that it has dealt with it, the stronger the case it can make to Israelis that their security can hold after Israeli troops withdraw. That confidence has to be earned in individual villages, through actions residents can see and results both sides can verify.
I want the investigation in Qabrikha to tell us what happened to those two riders and why the soldiers believed they were in danger. I also want something more durable for the part of Lebanon my grandfather called home. A resident who discovers rockets stored next door should know whom to call and have good reason to believe someone will come. An Israeli parent putting a child to bed across the border has a stake in that call being answered, too.
Comments
Add Your VoiceNo comments yet.