Skip to main content
100%
VoicesPolitics

Eisenkot Must Explain the Price of His Parliamentary Majority

As a Netanyahu supporter, I want answers about October 7. I also want to know what commitments would underpin an alternative government—and where its leaders would draw the line on Jerusalem and Jewis

I admire Benjamin Netanyahu and support his leadership. I disagree deeply with Gadi Eisenkot’s political approach, particularly his effort to assemble a parliamentary alternative whose potential supporters hold conflicting positions on Israel’s future.

The November 5 report about Eisenkot’s proposed Knesset committees brings that concern into focus. According to the report, he wants to advance legislation establishing a state commission of inquiry into October 7, alongside a broader effort to reverse judicial-overhaul legislation and secure influential parliamentary positions before a new government is formed.

An inquiry into the greatest security catastrophe in Israel’s history deserves serious consideration. So does the political arrangement through which Eisenkot intends to advance it. Voters deserve to understand both.

The reported program includes six to eight special committees, efforts to secure leadership of the Foreign Affairs and Defense and Finance committees, and a campaign to replace Knesset Speaker Amir Ohana. These remain proposed moves. Earlier reporting described disagreements within Eisenkot’s bloc over cooperation with Arab and ultra-Orthodox parties and the possibility of a unity government. Those differences will matter long after the first parliamentary vote.

Parties can agree to replace a speaker while disagreeing about borders, national identity, and security. The harder question comes when they need to pass a budget or respond to a crisis. At that point, whoever supplies the indispensable votes can demand a hearing.

Ahmad Tibi has said the Joint List is prepared to support an alternative government from outside the coalition. Yousef Jabareen has described initial contacts with opposition parties. Support from outside can still become essential to a government’s survival. The absence of a ministerial portfolio does little to resolve my concern about political dependence.

I want Eisenkot to explain the terms before asking the public to welcome the result.

The Joint List’s official platform calls for a sovereign Palestinian state on the pre-June 1967 lines, with East Jerusalem as its capital. It also calls for repealing the Nation-State Law and pursuing constitutional arrangements that recognize collective national rights for Arab citizens. These positions are publicly available. Any politician seeking the list’s support should expect questions about them.

My own position is clear. I oppose establishing a Palestinian state and transferring sovereignty over East Jerusalem to make it its capital. I believe Israel must remain the nation-state of the Jewish people, with Jerusalem as its capital. Those convictions would shape my judgment of any government, including one led by a politician I support.

I also believe every Israeli citizen deserves equal civil rights and effective public services. Cooperation on hospitals, infrastructure, education, or the fight against organized crime can be judged on its merits. A sustained governing arrangement raises additional questions about the national policies that keep its parliamentary supporters on board.

That is where I disagree with the approach Eisenkot is pursuing. Opposition to Netanyahu may bring politicians into the same room. It leaves unresolved what they would agree to do once they have the votes to exercise power.

Reporting on Yashar’s foundational program described Eisenkot as opposing Palestinian statehood under present circumstances and emphasizing the need to preserve a firm Jewish majority. That matters. It would be inaccurate to assume he has adopted the Joint List’s platform simply because its members may support him.

It also reveals the central difficulty. If one prospective partner regards Palestinian statehood as a national priority and another says it is currently unacceptable, how will they manage the disagreement?

Perhaps they will leave it outside their agreement. Perhaps one will demand a commitment to future negotiations. Perhaps the difference will prevent an arrangement altogether. The public should hear the answer from the participants.

Would Eisenkot reject a demand for a diplomatic commitment toward Palestinian statehood? Would he rule out changes to Jerusalem’s sovereignty? What commitments would he make about Jewish national self-determination? Would any understanding be published, including an arrangement for support from outside the coalition?

I have seen no signed agreement establishing that Eisenkot has conceded these points. My objection concerns the dependence he is considering and the unanswered questions it creates. Political scrutiny is most useful while choices are still being made.

Eisenkot’s party has published a proposal for a state commission of inquiry. He has also publicly called for an investigation reaching back years and examining both the political and military leadership. Those commitments should be assessed through the eventual legislation, its scope, and the independence of the process.

As a Netanyahu supporter, I want an investigation capable of establishing what officials knew, what assumptions shaped their decisions, and why the state failed to protect its citizens. Political leaders, military commanders, and intelligence officials should face questions grounded in evidence.

My support for Netanyahu comes with confidence that his record deserves a fair examination. An inquiry must be able to reach findings that disappoint supporters of any party. Its credibility will depend on whether Israelis can see that the evidence determines the conclusions.

Eisenkot should explain how his proposed legislation would achieve that confidence. The public needs to understand who would conduct the inquiry, how its remit would be defined, and how it would examine decisions across successive administrations and security leaderships.

I understand the parliamentary incentive to move quickly. Committee chairs and the speakership influence what receives attention and when. But speed does not answer the political questions behind the votes.

Eisenkot is asking Israelis to trust his judgment about the country’s next chapter. That includes his judgment about the partners whose support he may need. Their declared policies belong in that assessment.

My support remains with Netanyahu. To persuade me that his alternative could protect Israel’s national interests, Eisenkot would have to explain precisely how it would preserve Jewish self-determination, maintain Israeli sovereignty in Jerusalem, and make security decisions when essential parliamentary partners object.

Before the next agreement is celebrated, publish its commitments. Israelis should be able to read what has been promised in their name.

Voices are written by Community Members. The views, facts and pictures are the authors' own; TheStateOfIsrael.com does not verify or endorse them.

No comments yet.

Something went wrong

We couldn't complete that action. Check your connection and try again.