무함마드 셰하다
@muhammadshehad2 · 팔레스타인 인사
무함마드 셰하다는 유럽 인권옹호 활동과 연계된 가자 출신 논평가이자 분석가입니다.
"네타냐후는 [10월 9일] 분노가 폭발해 소리를 지르며 책상을 내리쳤다. 그는 참모총장을 꾸짖으며 말했다. '왜 5,000개가 아니지?' 할레비가 대답했다. '승인된 목표물이 5,000개는 없습니다.' 네타냐후가 받아쳤다. '나는 목표물에는 관심 없어. 집을 무너뜨리고, 가진 모든 것을 동원해 폭격해'"
영어에서 번역됨NAZA는 이스라엘이 가자에서 저지른 최악의 잔혹 행위조차 보여주지 않는다. 공습은 군인들이 지상에서 한 일(예: ‘모기 프로토콜’, 대량 학살, 모든 것의 파괴)에 비하면 아무것도 아니다. 이 영화가 군인들에게 침묵을 깨라고 부추기기 때문에 이스라엘은 NAZA를 두고 공황에 빠져 있다!
영어에서 번역됨These drones are often armed with explosives & guns Israel sends them into people's homes & tents to scan, shoot, drop grenades or explode Gaza is the laboratory for Israeli "startups" to field test those drones before exporting them to the world! We're a canary in a coal mine https://t.co/5wpwlUhwLB
Two things can be true: NAZA is a crucial documentary evidence against genocide deniers We live in a frighteningly hypocritical world that applauds Israelis who call out apartheid & genocide while shaming & disbelieving Palestinians who say the exact same words Like when German Culture Minister Claudia Roth said her applauds at 2024 Berlinale were solely directly at Israeli journalist Yuval Abraham & not his Palestinian co-director Basel Adra who was with him on stage An Israeli saying genocide & apartheid is "brave" & "extraordinary". A Palestinian using the same words is "radical", "extremist", "propagandist", "antisemite", & "uncompromising" Palestinian testimonies & evidence are treated as "biased", "exaggerated", "unreliable", until Israelis say otherwise! We need a former Israeli prime minister to say there's ethnic cleansing in the West Bank for European governments to believe it We need a former Israeli foreign minister to say that Camp David was a scam & that if he was a Palestinian he would've rejected it, in order to debunk the myth of the "most generous Israeli peace offer" We need the Israeli newspaper Haaretz to say Israel is torturing Palestinians to death in detention camps for the world to believe what we've been documenting & saying for years We always need an Israeli to add legitimacy & credibility to our meticulous & impeccable evidence That shouldn't mean discounting Israeli dissenting voices who speak up; it doesn't mean devaluing the important work they do & the risks they take when they call out their own country's crimes. There's already been a giant wave of attacks from Israeli government & opposition leaders against the filmmakers of NAZA Shame & anger should be directed at mainstream places who suppress & sideline Palestinian voices while elevating Israelis who say the exact same message The game is rigged against us. But that doesn't mean attacking Israeli dissidents like Yuval. It should rather mean that we & Israeli anti-apartheid activists should jointly call out & condemn those who set the rules of the game at every possible opportunity until Palestinian voices are heard & believed What do our people stand to gain from attacking Yuval & discrediting this movie? Activism is about what works, what makes a difference, not what feels good. NAZA is an important & crucial documentary that must be seen all around the world.
Here's the Jabalia massacre Israel says never happened! This refugee camp is only 1 square kilometer with over 100,000 inhabitants. Israel claimed the strike was targeting a junior Hamas commander who was never in that area to begin with. 897 people killed & maimed! https://t.co/suCNJfdpdu
You killed & maimed +897 civilians in a single attack on the Jabalia refugee camp on October 31, 2023 The massacre was so brutal, it led multiple countries to recall their ambassadors from Tel-Aviv; Bolivia cut all relations with Israel; the UN & EU condemned it Then you did it again & again
🚨Help needed in the Netherland: a Gazan woman received a PhD scholarship at Leiden University. Her & her partner are looking for a place to rent in Leiden, the Hague, Amsterdam, Rotterdam...etc, but can't find any. If you have any tips, please reach out.
Palestinians "celebrating" 9/11 is a HOAX! German TV report exposes how it was staged & edited manipulatively👇 On 9/11 our president & hundreds of Palestinians went to donate blood in Gaza. Every major Palestinian faction condemned the attack. Our schools observed a moment of silence. Palestinian in East Jerusalem lit up candles at the US consulate. Meanwhile, Netanyahu called 9/11 "very good" & "beneficial" for Israel!
On 9/11, Palestinian president Arafat condemned the attack & donated blood at the Shifa hospital, our schools observed a moment of silence, we lit candles & laid flowers at the U.S. Consulate in Jerusalem Netanyahu called the attack "very good" & Israel "is benefiting from [it]" https://t.co/syFKVAO3ag
Given your record of lying pathologically about who was rejecting the ceasefire, your denial here is meaningless One of your very own senior officials described you to me as "deeply biased, incompetent & coward" They said you suppressed internal reports, refused to listen to your own State Dep & kept telling them "why would Netanyahu lie to me" & "you don't know how to talk to the Israelis" They said 90% of the State Dep were against your policy, & whenever you held a meeting for the top State Dep officials & the overwhelming majority of them recommended different actions, but you always sided with the one pro-Israel voice in the room
Three weeks before Oct 7, Sinwar himself sent a warning to Israel: "Convey a message to them that I am preparing the mother of all surprises. A terrifying operation. Something extraordinary." Again, he rolled the word "zilzal," earthquake, on his tongue. "Please convey to the Israelis what I am saying word for word" Sinwar's warning came after he had engaged in negotiations with Israel for 5 years for a mutual ceasefire, ending Israel's suffocation of Gaza's economy & gradually easing the blockade. Whenever the two sides came close to deal, Netanyahu procrastinated The UAE and Egypt warned Netanyahu that Sinwar wasn't joking & that he was going to launch a major surprise attack. The UAE asked Netanyahu to alleviate the suffering in Gaza & defuse tensions in the West Bank to dissuade Sinwar from attacking, Netanyahu ignored every one of those warnings
Sinwar, Egypt & UAE warned Israel of "mother of all surprises" & "earthquake", Netanyahu ignored Hamas engaged in negotiations from 2018 to Sep 2023 to lift Israel's siege, Netanyahu kept procrastinating Hamas offered to release all civilian hostages on Oct 7, Netanyahu refused https://t.co/b6oYPEcM0q
למי אכפת שנתניהו הפסיד את קנדה, דנמרק, פינלנד, צרפת, איסלנד, אירלנד, נורבגיה, פולין, פורטוגל, ספרד, שבדיה ובריטניה? ישראל קיבלה את נאורו, סומלילנד, מיקרונזיה, פפואה גינאה החדשה, קוסובו ופיג'י!
Multiple big steps in the right direction: Calling settler terrorism by its name Deeming Israel's occupation unlawful Recognizing West Bank ethnic cleansing & war crimes in Gaza Recognizing a problem & calling it by its name is the most crucial stepping stone towards solving it Banning settlement products & vowing to crack down on settler terrorism & take "action on services to target those who finance, facilitate or construct new settlements" are all a great start. Especially given the Trump administration's pressure. Next is: 1- Making the most logical conclusion: that if an occupation is illegal, permanent & disenfranchises millions of Palestinians, that equals a system of apartheid 2- Recognizing genocide in Gaza & acting accordingly 3- Imposing sanctions on companies & institutions operating in Israeli settlements, not just vowing to punish those who participate in "new settlements." Even Rahm Emanuel is now in favour of sanctioning Israeli companies & banks that work in settlements 4- Suspending all arm sales to Israel that enable or are used to carry out what the UK gov now officially recognises as illegal occupation, ethnic cleansing & war crimes 5- Imposing sanctions on Israeli government officials, military commanders & soldiers implicated in the illegal occupation, ethnic cleansing & war crimes
Israel's UN ambassador is admitting what the Board of Peace & IDF denied when I called them out: "The rubbles are coming out... that was the request of the Board of Peace, & Israel accepted that, & we are working with the Board of Peace to start pilots"
Predictable! UK sanctions on Israeli settlements are "symbolic & will have no material impact on the UK's wider relationship with Israel" World leaders are still treating Israel's genocide & apartheid as a mere "PR crisis" & a "reputation management" handled through change in rhetorics but not actions
أنهيت للتو مشاهدة حلقة بودكاست تقارب مع @motazazaiza9 كاملة، بدلاً من الحكم على شخصه من مشاهد ريلز قصيرة سواء اتفقتم أم اختلفتم مع آراءه، أسلوبه أو شخصيته، الشب نظيف، بيحاول أفضل ما عنده وكان بيحكي اللي في قلبه بصدق شعوره بالغضب والألم والاكتئاب وعقدة الناجي وخيبة الأمل والصدمة يعبر عن كل غزة إذا عندكم تحفظات على شيء قاله أو فعله، فالنصيحة أفضل بمليون مرة من تحطيم المعنويات وحملات الإلغاء والتخوين، خصوصاً لشخص موجوع بشدة، بحاجة لتطييب الخاطر، أقل كلمة ممكن تؤذيه وتزيد ألمه "رَحِمَ الله امرَأً أهدى إليَّ عيوبي" كما قال سيدنا عمر. ليس فينا أحد بلا عيوب، لكن إهداء العيوب لا يكون بالفضح والمعايرة الرسول (ص) نهى الصحابة عن قول "أخزاكَ اللَّه" حتى لرجل سكران وقال "لا تقولوا هكذا، لا تُعينوا عليهِ الشَّيطان" سواء أعجبتكم شخصيته وآراؤه أم لا، الشب له قبول دولي واسع وصوته مسموع في كثير أماكن صعب للفلسطيني يكون فيها واللوبي الإسرائيلي شن ضده حملات تشويه هائلة. شو النتيجة اللي هدمه أو إلغاؤه راح يحققها؟ معتز ومثله من الشباب الفلسطيني الموهوب المفروض احتواءهم والاستثمار فيهم، لأن نجاح هؤلاء الشباب نجاح إلنا كلنا
On Oct 6: 81.5% of Gazans were living in poverty 47% unemployed (62.3% of youth) 71% screened positive for depression 91% of children had PTSD 22,000 orphans 36,142 protesters wounded by Israel in 2018/19 2,000 amputees $1.6 billion in economic losses annually from Israel's siege alone (half the size of Gaza's entire GDP) A 20 year-old Gazan had survived 4 Israeli wars & 12 military assaults Most Gazans had never stepped a foot outside this giant "open air prison" (as UK PM David Cameron called it) An entire people forsaken, caged, impoverished, traumatised, periodically massacred, made futureless & left to languish & die in the "biggest concentration camp ever created on earth" (as prominent Israeli sociologist Baruch Kimmerling put it). Showing a single affluent neighbourhood where only the upper class lived is dumb propaganda!
"The nucleus of this issue was what happened in Gaza, & we need to go back to that, starting with recent developments in the strait of Hormuz & ending with finding a solution for the Palestinian issue. This cannot be dealt with as an afterthought" - Qatar's PM advisor
FALSE! Not a single Palestinian faction has officially claimed Abdallah as a militant The source of that AI-generated pic below is an obscure instagram page created only 7 weeks ago, & it doesn't name which faction he was supposedly a member of. It only says "martyr struggler"
🚨Israeli soldiers who GANG RAPED a Palestinian hostage on camera are suing for a $6,000,000 compensation from the Israeli gov after the Israeli army dropped all charges against them (despite a mountain of evidence)! https://t.co/SX1d5PgCSp
YOU MURDERED 1500 Palestinians since that ceasefire started & you have the audacity to whine about someone crossing an invisible illegal line inside Gaza?
I've never laughed that hard while doing a political interview. @DanielBMate & @mattlieb were definitely two of my all time favorite hosts. A discussion about "the packed clown car of political appointees & toadies lining up to profit from Gaza torment": https://t.co/g5a4O8v28G
That's why all the talk about "Palestinian Authority reform" is garbage Israel will keep moving the goalpost indefinitely! It started with "remove any reference to armed resistance" & now we're at "replace Palestine with Samaria" Next name every first born Benzion!
Update: the IDF denies receiving any foreign funding for demolition work & rubble removal in Gaza. Board of Peace tweeted an unspecified denial Both are yet to answer my detailed follow up questions My sources informed me the IDF & private contractors have been doing rubble removal & road paving work in Gaza, & that the Board of Peace is allegedly contributing to these expenses I have seen, among other things, satellite footage to corroborate significant recent rubble removal & a tender issued under the name of the Board of Peace that included "levelling & compaction" work in East Gaza EU diplomats told me Israel has been transferring "hundreds of thousands of tons of rubble mixed with human remains" outside Gaza. When an EU diplomat asked why or whether Israel makes any effort to filter human remains out of the rubble, they never received an answer!
연결된 기사
- IDF Chief Orders Legal and Security Review of ‘Naza’ Film
- Israel Film Council Sets Urgent Festival-Scoring Review After ‘Naza’
- Bennett Says He Knows UAE Warning to Netanyahu Was Genuine
- Four Opposition Leaders Pledge Oct. 7 State Inquiry After UAE Warning Report
- UAE Leader Warned Netanyahu of Hamas Move Before October 7, Report Says
- UAE Says It Does Not Comment on Reports About Leaders’ Conversations
- Netanyahu Orders Lawyers to File Libel Suit Over UAE Warning Report
- Nauru Opens Embassy in Jerusalem, Ninth Country With a Mission in Israel’s Capital
- UK Announces Import Ban and Sanctions Regime Targeting Settlement Trade
- IDF Eliminates Two Terrorists Who Crossed Gaza’s Yellow Line
- IDF Kills Terrorist Who Crossed Gaza’s Yellow Line and Threatened Troops