Judicial Ombudsman Warns Judges Against Initiating Searches of Litigants’ Phones
Judicial Ombudsman Asher Kula has instructed judges to refrain from initiating searches of litigants’ or witnesses’ digital devices without an explicit request and an opportunity to be heard. The Justice Ministry published the retired judge’s conclusions on November 17, following a complaint about a judge’s inspection of a mobile phone during an evidentiary hearing in a civil proceeding. The litigant complained that the judge took his phone and examined its contact list without informed consent. He alleged that the judge exploited the courtroom’s power imbalance, failed to explain that he could refuse and infringed his privacy. The complainant also alleged hostility and judicial bias. The judge responded that the Civil Procedure Regulations allow a court to order the presentation of any document, a category he argued included a phone and its contacts. He said he sought to uncover the truth and prevent false testimony after hearing testimony that appeared unreliable. He maintained that privacy was not absolute and that the inspection was limited to the contacts and dialer. Kula rejected that interpretation as mistaken and far-reaching, finding the judge’s conduct defective. Citing the Supreme Court’s Public Defender case, he said smartphones contain intimate information and that inspecting them affects the core constitutional right to privacy and requires explicit legal authorization. When specific information is needed, he instructed courts to have device owners locate and display it themselves, “not to perform the action in their place.” Kula also said judges must proactively explain the legal right to object and the examination’s limits, given the inherent imbalance of power in court.

Commentary
Loading comments…