Italy Approves Antisemitism Law Adopting IHRA Definition
Italy’s Chamber of Deputies gave final approval on November 17 to legislation combating antisemitism and adopting the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s working definition. The measure passed with 147 votes in favor, 93 against and five abstentions, completing its passage through parliament. The center-right supported it alongside Italia Viva, while most of the opposition opposed the bill. The law adopts the IHRA definition together with its explanatory examples, including examples concerning certain forms of criticism of Israel. It provides for preventive measures and monitoring without creating new specific criminal offenses. Existing legislation, including the Mancino law, already addresses criminal conduct in this area. The legislation provides for a national strategy covering three years and a national antisemitism coordinator based at the Presidency of the Council of Ministers. Its monitoring measures concern antisemitic incidents and hate crimes. During the debate, PD, Avs, +Europa and M5S sought to replace the IHRA definition with the Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism, which defines hostility toward Jews as Jews without referring to Israel. The government and the bill’s rapporteur, Paolo Emilio Russo, opposed the proposed changes, which were rejected in voting. Defending the legislation, Russo said: “No one in this chamber ever dreamed of limiting the right to political criticism.” The vote also exposed divisions within the Democratic Party: Piero Fassino had announced that he and other colleagues would depart from the party’s voting instructions.

Commentary
Loading comments…