Liberman Denies Having a Conscription Framework, Sets Three Conditions for a Law
Avigdor Liberman, chairman of the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee and leader of Yisrael Beiteinu, denied on Thursday evening, November 19, that he had prepared a conscription framework. His response followed a report that the committee's legal adviser opposed a developing framework attributed to him. Liberman said: “There is no paper.” He also said he had not discussed the matter with anyone. He reiterated three checkpoints that conscription legislation must pass: the IDF chief of staff, the High Court of Justice and the rabbis. Alongside those conditions, he said he had asked for a review mapping the comments that High Court judges had made during petitions against earlier frameworks. Political reporter Amit Segal, who published the original claim, stood by his account. He argued that the requirements Liberman described constituted a framework even without a document formally bearing that name. In Segal's account, seeking rabbinical agreement while basing legislation on Liberman's 2018 proposal would yield a more lenient law than the proposal associated with Boaz Bismuth. Segal said Liberman's 2018 proposal had lacked personal sanctions. He also said the committee's legal adviser had opposed Bismuth's proposal, and argued that a stricter measure would not obtain rabbinical agreement.
Sources
Difference in reporting
Sources factually disagree on whether a conscription framework exists: Srugim reports Liberman's denial that he has a framework or document; Amit Segal maintains that Liberman's stated requirements amount to a framework. Both accounts identify the military, judicial and rabbinical requirements as the basis of the dispute.


Commentary