Chief Rabbi Kalman Ber Calls for Same-Sex Physiotherapy Training
Chief Rabbi Kalman Meir Ber has called on universities and colleges to arrange physiotherapy practice between students of the same sex. In a halakhic letter published on November 21, the president of the Chief Rabbinate Council ruled against compulsory exercises involving men and women where there is no genuine medical or professional need. The letter followed an appeal by Rabbi Binyamin Tabadi after religious female students were required to practice on male classmates and allow men to practice on them. Tabadi said the exercises involved physical contact and sometimes exposure of parts of the body. He said he examined the medical and halakhic questions, ruled against participation in most cases and approached Ber after colleges resisted the students’ requests. “There is no medical or professional need for female students to practice on male students, or male students on female students,” Ber wrote. He said students should not participate even if their institution required it. He distinguished exercises for educational purposes from treatment of an actual patient, while saying modesty requirements and a preference for same-sex treatment where possible also applied to medical care. Ber cited rulings by the Chazon Ish, the Steipler, Rabbi Yitzhak Yaakov Weiss, Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Auerbach and Rabbi Ovadia Yosef concerning treatment between men and women. He criticized institutions’ handling of observant students and the lack of protest from women’s-rights organizations. He urged university and college administrations to change their procedures so practical training could take place between students of the same sex.

Commentary