Skip to main content

Video Shows Rabbi Hirsch Advising Released Yeshiva Student to Continue Torah Study

A video published Saturday shows Rabbi Moshe Hillel Hirsch advising newly married yeshiva student Yaari Liberman to continue Torah study rather than accept a military service track offered to him. Liberman visited the rabbi after his release from military detention. The report does not specify when their conversation took place. Liberman described a choice between entering a track intended to accommodate Haredi religious observance and continuing his studies in kollel while risking detention again. He told Hirsch that he would follow the rabbi's decision. According to the account accompanying the recording, his release required him to report again for military service. Hirsch advised against enlistment and explained his concerns about the assurances being offered, the effect that Liberman's decision could have on other yeshiva students, and his continued religious observance. Hirsch said, "It will lower the morale of many, many young men." He concluded the conversation by giving Liberman a blessing. The account says Liberman was detained during the week of celebrations following his wedding, after an earlier unsuccessful attempt to detain him. In the conversation, Liberman also described religious difficulties during detention, saying that a female soldier had interrupted him during the Amidah prayer. Those details were his account of his experience; the newly published recording centers on the religious guidance he sought after his release.

Sources

Secondary sources:1
Courtroom-sketch editorial illustration of an open Torah scroll and silver pointer, based on an archival museum photograph as Torah-study context, without depicting Rabbi Hirsch or the recorded conversation

Commentary

Add Your Voice
Loading comments…

Related articles

  1. Zamir Tells Haredi Yeshiva Students IDF Service Must Preserve Their Religious Identity
  2. Miki Zohar Opposes Personal Sanctions on Haredi Torah Students
  3. Likud Says Netanyahu Backs Enlistment for Haredi Men Not Studying Torah
  4. Meirav Cohen Says Opposition Blocked Conscription Bill and Criticizes Netanyahu
  5. Asher Backs Rabbi Dov Landau and Calls for Respect for Haredi Religious Autonomy

Voices

Write about this

Something went wrong

We couldn't complete that action. Check your connection and try again.