High Court Extends Stay on Private-Space Cameras in Geriatric Hospitals Until 2028
Israel’s High Court of Justice on Wednesday extended an interim order suspending requirements for cameras in private spaces in geriatric hospitals until January 1, 2028. Justices Daphne Barak-Erez, Ofer Grosskopf and Alex Stein closed the petition brought by the Association of Nursing Homes and Assisted Living in Israel, while criticizing the government and Knesset’s handling of the legislation. Barak-Erez wrote that “certain aspects of the law cannot be implemented in their current form.” The court ordered the state and Knesset to pay the association NIS 20,000 in legal costs. It concluded that continued judicial supervision was unnecessary after the state undertook to amend the law. The parties had sought different arrangements as the case drew to a close. The state, association and Knesset asked to keep the petition open for further progress reports. If it was closed, the state proposed extending the interim protection for another year, while the association sought an order without an expiry date. The Knesset opposed extending the interim order after the petition was removed. The legislation, published in January 2019, was intended in part to protect geriatric-hospital patients through cameras. The association petitioned later that year over budgetary and technological difficulties, and the court issued the agreed interim order on January 6, 2020. In November 2024, the state said the health minister had decided to pursue a targeted amendment concerning private spaces. An August 9, 2026 court decision recorded a July 30 government update saying interministerial work on a draft legislative memorandum was continuing without a completion timetable. The latest ruling keeps the private-space provisions suspended through the new January 2028 deadline.

Commentary