Mamdani Defends October 7 Statement and Repeats Genocide Accusation Against Israel
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani defended his October 7 anniversary statement during a November 18 interview at the DealBook summit in New York. He again accused Israel’s government of committing genocide against Palestinians while explaining why he combined remembrance of Hamas’s attack with criticism of Israel. Interviewer Andrew Ross Sorkin asked whether the anniversary should have been reserved for condemning Hamas’s atrocities, with criticism of Israel expressed the following day. Mamdani argued that October 7 is repeatedly invoked to justify subsequent Israeli military action and said its commemoration should address the consequences that followed. “I have a politics of universality,” Mamdani said, presenting his position as applying the same values to Israelis and Palestinians. In his October 7 post, marking three years since the Hamas attack, Mamdani described the group’s acts as horrific war crimes and expressed grief for people killed and abducted. Israel has rejected genocide allegations. In a May 24, 2024 joint statement, the head of Israel’s National Security Council and the Foreign Ministry spokesperson rejected the charges brought by South Africa at the International Court of Justice. They said Israel’s campaign followed Hamas’s October 7 attack and sought to eliminate Hamas and free the hostages, while affirming commitments to humanitarian aid and reducing civilian harm.

Commentary